Pegasus

Navigate

Services

Premium Programs

Get Started
WePegasus Blog
Career

One Harvard paper just handed Washington its favourite number on Indian tech talent

Will the New Harvard H-1B Wage Study Hurt My H1B Visa After MBA Plans?

Gauri Manohar
Gauri Manohar
6 min read · Nov 18, 2026

If you are an Indian engineer with a computer science master's, sitting on a Round 2 shortlist of US schools and quietly betting that an H1B visa after MBA will pay off the loan, this week's headline probably made your stomach drop. On 16 November 2026, Harvard economist George Borjas released an NBER working paper arguing that H-1B and OPT workers pushed down earnings for American graduates in exactly the fields many Indian applicants come from. The paper does not change any rule today. It does change the argument Washington will use for the next set of rules.

What the Borjas paper actually found

The paper, The Labor Market Impact of Temporary High-Skill Immigration Programs (NBER Working Paper 36014), starts from a count: roughly 1.2 million foreign workers were employed in the US in 2019 through temporary high-skill programmes, with H-1B and OPT named explicitly. Borjas identifies likely temporary workers in the American Community Survey and measures how many sit in each education level and field of degree.

His headline estimates, per the NBER abstract:

Group Estimated earnings effect
US natives with science and engineering degrees About 3.5% lower
US natives with master's in computing or electrical and computer engineering About 16% lower
Average wage gain from production complementarities About 1.4% higher

The paper also reports a relative decline in full-time, year-round work for natives in the most exposed groups. Its one-line conclusion is that, absent wider spillovers, these programmes mainly redistribute earnings rather than create them.

Two technical points matter for how you read this. First, Borjas models "stayers", people who arrive on a temporary visa and remain after it ends, which pushes the estimated effect higher than a simple headcount would. Second, this is a working paper. Immigration Analytics notes that NBER papers are released before peer review, and it points to counter-evidence, including a Cato Institute commentary and a peer-reviewed H-1B lottery study, that reaches gentler conclusions.

Why the timing matters more than the numbers

Economists have argued about H-1B wage effects for twenty years. What is new is the policy appetite. Business Standard reports that in September the administration renewed the $100,000 fee on new H-1B petitions, and in October suspended eight large technology firms, including Microsoft and Adobe, from sponsoring green cards. Borjas served on the Council of Economic Advisers, and an earlier paper of his made the case for a six-figure H-1B fee.

So read this paper less as a verdict and more as ammunition. A "16% wage cut for American computing graduates" line is easy to quote in a hearing. The part most Indian applicants miss is that the paper groups OPT alongside H-1B. Immigration Analytics argues the findings could be used to support an OPT fee, which lines up with the $70,000 OPT fee proposal already in the pipeline. OPT is the bridge every international MBA uses to get from graduation to the H-1B lottery. If that bridge becomes expensive, your post-MBA plan changes even if H-1B rules stay put.

Our read, after 13 years of placing Indian applicants: this is not a reason to panic, but it is a reason to stop treating US work authorisation as a default outcome. It is now a variable you have to plan around.

If you are an IT services or product engineer targeting a US MBA for tech roles

You are the profile the paper is about. The 16% figure is specifically for computing and electrical engineering master's holders, and recruiters in US tech know this debate well. Expect sponsoring employers to be more selective, and expect pressure to justify above-floor salaries, which the DOL prevailing wage changes are already pushing.

What helps: a post-MBA goal that is not "software engineer, again". Product management, strategy and corporate development roles sit in MBA pay bands that sit well above the wage floors under debate. Your essays should make that pivot specific and credible, not generic.

If you are a consultant, banker or CA targeting a US M7

Your degree field is not in the paper's most exposed group, so the direct wage argument touches you less. The indirect risk is OPT. A fee or tighter rules on OPT hit every international MBA, regardless of background. Build your school list with at least two programmes outside the US, in markets such as the UK, Singapore or Canada, so one policy decision cannot sink the whole cycle.

What this means for Indian applicants

Three practical moves for anyone applying in Round 2 or planning Fall 2027:

  1. Run the ROI at zero US work years. If the loan only makes sense with three years of US salary, the plan is fragile. Our ROI comparison for MBA abroad shows how to stress-test it.
  2. Favour STEM-designated MBAs. STEM OPT still gives up to three lottery attempts. See our breakdown of H-1B and STEM OPT for Indian MBA applicants.
  3. Write a goal that works in India too. Admissions committees now read "I will stay in the US" with more scepticism. A goal with a credible India or Asia path reads as lower risk.

If you want a second pair of eyes on whether your profile still clears the bar, our profile evaluation and career counselling sessions model exactly these scenarios.

Common questions

Does the Borjas study change H-1B rules right now?

No. It is a research paper, not a regulation. Nothing about the H-1B lottery, the $100,000 fee or OPT changes because of it. Its effect is political: it gives policymakers a fresh, citable number when they defend existing restrictions or propose new ones, such as an OPT fee.

Is an H1B visa after MBA still realistic for Indian students?

Yes, but less automatic. MBA hires tend to sit in higher pay bands than the entry-level tech roles at the centre of this debate, which helps under wage-weighted selection. The bigger risk is cost and employer hesitation, so apply to STEM-designated programmes and keep a non-US fallback.

Does the study cover OPT or just H-1B?

The NBER abstract names both H-1B and OPT in its count of temporary high-skill workers. That is why commentators are linking it to OPT fee proposals, and why international students should watch it closely.

Should I switch from US to UK or Canada because of this?

Not on the strength of one paper. Diversify instead. Keep your strongest US targets and add one or two programmes in markets with stable post-study work routes.


Sources verified 18 November 2026. Figures are from NBER Working Paper 36014 as summarised in its abstract and in reporting by Business Standard and Immigration Analytics. Next review: 1 January 2028.

CareerAdmissions Strategy

Have thoughts on this?

We read every response. Whether it is a question about your application, a different perspective, or just to say the article helped, reach out.

Write to us